Thought Piece

The Navy Held Tryouts

John Ferry

·

Seven boats showed up, six could play, three made the roster — and the practice squad got paid.

Every fall, youth-sports parents learn the difference between a draft and a tryout. A draft is a bet on paper: last season's stats, a coach's recommendation, a highlight reel edited by somebody's dad. A tryout is simpler. Show up Saturday morning, run the drills, and the kids who can play, play.

For most of its history, defense acquisition has drafted off the highlight reel. You win a big program with a proposal — hundreds of pages describing, in confident future tense, the thing you will eventually build. The source selection board reads the binders, scores the promises, and picks a winner who then spends years discovering the gap between the paper and the product.

Last week, the Navy held a tryout instead.

On September 29 the Navy announced production agreements for 30 medium unmanned surface vessels (MUSVs, if you're filling out the roster card), split three ways: 10 hulls each to Saronic, HII, and Galliano Marine Service of the Edison Chouest family. And in case you want a stat for your own slide deck, make it this one.

Per the Navy's September 29, 2026 announcement, the service committed roughly $1.2 billion for 30 medium unmanned surface vessels at an average cost of $40 million per hull, with first deliveries expected as early as the fourth quarter of FY27 — about six months after the competition's go-straight-to-water structure was rolled out in March.

The draft era, in one boat

To appreciate the change, rewind to the first time the Navy tried to buy this exact capability. In July 2020, NAVSEA awarded L3 Technologies $35 million to design and build a single MUSV prototype, with options for up to eight more and a ceiling of $281 million. Delivery was expected in early FY23. Then the years did what years do in prototype land. A follow-on prototyping program called MASC stood up in 2025 and got cancelled in March 2026. The first production order for a medium USV arrived last week — six years, one restructuring, and one cancelled program after that first award.

So what changed? The Navy stopped asking industry to describe boats and started asking industry to show up with one.

The March 2026 rules read like an open audition. Make the cut on paper and attend the post-award conference: $10,000, basically gas money. Get your boat through at-sea trials by the end of FY26: $15 million. Beat the other boats on the water: a production order. Rebecca Gassler, the portfolio acquisition executive running the effort, said the point was to "test the capability on water and go straight into production," shaving about a year off the usual route. The money was already parked — $2.1 billion that Congress carved out for MUSVs in the July 2025 reconciliation bill.

Tryout day

Seven companies brought boats. The drills were not gentle: 2,500 nautical miles at 25 knots through sea state 4, hauling 25 metric tons in a pair of 40-foot containers, plus long autonomous legs of 360-plus nautical miles with the operators mostly keeping their hands in their pockets. Six passed. Three made the roster, and all three are building in Louisiana bayou country — Saronic in Franklin at the old Gulf Craft yard, HII with Breaux Brothers in Loreauville, and Galliano down in Houma.

Now the part every program office should photocopy. Leidos, PacMar Technologies, and Sea Machines passed trials without landing a production order, and they still collected $15 million each and a listing on the Drones.mil maritime marketplace, where program offices can find them for follow-on orders. That's a practice squad: paid, warm, and one roster move away from a jersey. Even Birdon, the one entrant that didn't pass, was told it has "a viable path" forward. Phase 2 opens for testing on November 16 with rolling evaluations planned for five years. The gym stays open.

How is any of this legal without a two-year source selection? Because the bridge has been sitting in Title 10 the whole time. Under 10 U.S.C. 4022(f), a competitively awarded prototype other transaction that is successfully completed can roll straight into follow-on production without a new competition. The CICA box got checked at the prototype gate, on the water, where it is considerably harder to win on font selection.

Yes, the lawyers showed up anyway — Blue Water Autonomy and Saildrone have filed suit over the selection criteria. Tryouts make for cleaner rosters and angrier agents. Nobody litigates a participation trophy.

Photocopy the tryout

For the government side: this structure travels. A small check for showing up, a real check for finishing trials, production reserved for whoever wins on the water, and a standing marketplace shelf so the next order starts from a depth chart instead of a blank page. Every piece of that is doable today with authorities you already hold. The authorities have been on the books for years; the new ingredient was a program office willing to let the water do the scoring.

For industry: the ticket to this game is a working boat, and that cuts both ways. If your edge is engineering, your sea trial is your proposal, and the B&P budget you used to burn on binders goes into steel and autonomy software. If your edge is a proposal shop... tryouts are bad news, and it's worth saying so before your next raise or your next bid decision.

And spare a thought for the contracting officers and lawyers who structured this — somebody had to put gas money into a government agreement and defend it. Put those folks on stage at the next acquisition symposium, because the workforce copies what gets celebrated.

Thirty hulls with delivery dates is a real order, the kind demo days never seem to produce. The paper draft bought one prototype and six years of waiting. The tryout put three production lines to work inside six months, kept three more builders paid and on the shelf, and left the door open for the next boat that can pass the physical.

Run it back.