Defective Pricing

Defective pricing occurs when certified cost or pricing data were inaccurate, incomplete, or noncurrent as of the date of price agreement. Under FAR 15.407-1 the government is entitled to a price reduction, including profit or fee, for any significant resulting increase.

Defective pricing is the enforcement side of the Truthful Cost or Pricing Data statutes. When certified data prove inaccurate, incomplete, or noncurrent as of the date of final agreement on price, the government is entitled to a price reduction, profit or fee included, for any significant resulting increase (FAR 15.407-1; 10 U.S.C. 3706; 41 U.S.C. 3506). The clauses at 52.215-10 and 52.215-11 reach prime and subcontractor data alike.

Most cases arrive as a DCAA post-award audit finding. The contracting officer must let the contractor support the data's accuracy, completeness, and currency before determining defectiveness, then document and report the determination under 42.1503(h). Offsets for understated data run only up to the government's claim in the same pricing action, and never where the contractor knew of the understatement before the as-of date.

Interest accrues on overpayments at Treasury rates under 26 U.S.C. 6621(a)(2), and a knowing submission adds a penalty equal to the overpayment (10 U.S.C. 3707; 41 U.S.C. 3507). The classic trap is the sweep: quotes and actuals that move between the data cutoff and the handshake, disclosed to no one.

Regulatory Reference

FAR 15.407-1; FAR 52.215-10; FAR 52.215-11; 10 U.S.C. 3706-3707; 41 U.S.C. 3506-3507

RFO Status

The Part 15 model deviation (posted September 30, 2025) moves defective pricing from 15.407-1 to a new section 15.304, Defective Certified Cost or Pricing Data After Award, in the postaward subpart, with the price-adjustment entitlement, interest, and knowing-submission penalty preserved; GSA adopted the deviated part as class deviation RFO-2025-15 effective November 3, 2025, and DoD as class deviation 2026-O0048 (issued March 5, 2026). Part 15 is not among the June 23, 2026 first-batch proposed rules, so published 15.407-1 remains the baseline absent an agency deviation. (verified September 25, 2026)

Category

Processes & Methods

How AcqBot Helps

AcqBot ties each cost element in a certified proposal to its source data and date, so a sweep before the certificate catches quotes and actuals that moved after negotiations opened, and it assembles the disclosure record showing what was provided, to whom, and when if the price is questioned later.