Cost Realism Analysis

Cost realism analysis is the independent review of each offeror's proposed cost elements to determine whether they are realistic for the work, reflect a clear understanding of the requirements, and are consistent with the offeror's own technical approach. FAR 15.404-1(d) governs.

On cost-reimbursement competitions the analysis is mandatory. Evaluators develop a probable cost for each offeror (the government's best estimate of what the resulting contract will actually cost), and that probable cost, not the proposed figure, is used for evaluation to determine best value (FAR 15.404-1(d)(2)). A lowball cost volume gains nothing; the evaluation adjusts it back up.

On fixed-price work the tool changes character. It may be used on competitive fixed-price incentive contracts or, in exceptional cases, other fixed-price types, but proposals are evaluated against the solicitation criteria and offered prices are not adjusted as a result of the analysis (15.404-1(d)(3)). The review informs the risk picture; the price stands.

The errors run in both directions: taking proposed costs at face value on a cost-type source selection skips a required step, while adjusting an offered price after a fixed-price realism review does what (d)(3) forbids.

Regulatory Reference

FAR 15.404-1(d)

RFO Status

The Part 15 model deviation (released September 30, 2025) restructures contracting by negotiation and carries cost realism analysis at section 15.404-3; DoD conformed DFARS 215 through class deviation 2026-O0048 (issued March 5, 2026; effective March 16, 2026). Part 15 is not among the June 23, 2026 first-batch proposed rules. (verified September 21, 2026)

Category

Processes & Methods

How AcqBot Helps

AcqBot builds the probable-cost worksheet from each offeror's technical approach, documents the element-by-element adjustments the 15.404-1(d) record must support, and keeps fixed-price evaluations on the right side of the no-adjustment rule.